Buttery Soft Pretzels Without Baking Soda

Name: Buttery Soft Pretzels Without Baking Soda Bath
Prep time: 40 min
Cook time: 13 min
Total time: 1 h 23 min
Yield: 8
Cuisine: American
Ingredients: 1 1/2 c water; 1 tbsp active dry yeast; 1 tbsp sugar + 1/2 tsp, sepparated; 4 c flour; 2 1/2 tsp salt; 3 tbsp butter, melted; 1 egg; 1 tbsp water; kosher salt; melted butter, for spreading over cooked pretzels (however much you want)

Published:April 13, 2020 Updated:April 11, 2021 35 Comments

Jump to Recipe

Super fluffy, buttery, salty and insanely addicting. Say goodbye to the baking soda bath and all that extra work, we won’t be using that method for these soft pretzels without baking soda!

Homemade baked soft pretzels are on the agenda today and I've got a recipe for you that won't disappoint.

soft pretzels without baking soda on a plate

Recipe photos updated 06/19/20.

This recipe for soft pretzels without the baking soda is my absolute favorite way to make pretzels! Truth be told, you don't 'need' to dip them in a baking soda bath, see all that gorgeous golden sheen in my photos?

100% made by a quick trip under the broiler and a brushing of melted butter.

I've been making soft pretzels since I was kid, so you could say I'm sort of an old pro by now.

Every time I make soft pretzels I get my kids involved and let them roll and shape the pretzels. But the most important job of all, the official pretzel taste tester, they do that job quite well.

They key to a great soft pretzel is extra butter. Butter makes everything better. Plus there's always all the yummy pretzels dippings.

My son loves to dip his soft pretzels in cream cheese, so delicious.

It's actually a whole family thing, we all do it, we're all guilty of being cream cheese pretzel dippers.

How To Form A Soft Pretzel

Here's a little step by step on how to form a soft pretzel.

Start with a small piece of dough cut off from your large piece (I cut mine in to 8 even pieces from the original dough ball).

Use the palms of your hands to roll the dough in to a long rope. The longer the rope, the larger but thinner pretzel. The shorter the rope, the smaller but fatter pretzel.

Take the two end pieces and bring them together, away from you. Twist the two pieces together, like the picture.

twist dough into a soft pretzel on a flat surface

Take the twisted ends and bring them toward you, so the ends slightly overlap the bottom.

soft pretzel without baking soda formed prior to baking on a flat surface

*note - don't dust flour on your counter while rolling out the dough into ropes unless your dough is super sticky, if your dough is a little on the dry side you can wet the palms of your hands to gain traction

How long do the soft pretzels take to make?

They take about an hour from start to finish.

Which is all I can muster to wait when that buttery, salty, soft pretzel craving strikes!

Soft pretzels don't have to take all day.

These are a quick prep and a quick bake, since we're leaving out the baking soda bath it knocks off a lot of the normal pretzel making time. Because when you did the pretzels into the baking soda it adds quite a bit of time to the process.

baking sheet of cooked soft pretzels without baking soda

Resting Soft Pretzel Dough

There isn't a ton of 'resting' time for this recipe. The initial bit of rest time after the dough comes together and then you move right along in to making them.

You'll skip the traditional pretzel resting time after you form them in to pretzels. Go straight in to brushing with the egg wash and baking.

hands holding a ball of dough for soft pretzels

All the resting time that we are skipping saves so much time.

Now it doesn't mean that you can't rest them. You totally can. But know you don't have to. If you watch in my video, after my dough has puffed up I don't have any more resting time allotted.

Why no baking soda bath?

Opting out of a baking soda bath cuts down the time it takes to make these by like half.

A baking soda bath is actually a cheat for at home pretzel makers, it's used instead of lye, which can be a bit dangerous to handle if you aren't a professional in that area.

This is what gives pretzels that dark, shimmering outer crust.

I don't know about you, but for me the whole pretzel experience is how soft and fluffy they are.

You won't get the extra crisp crust with this recipe but you will get super yummy fluffy pretzels. To create a bit of color I end the cooking process with a quick broil.

Your family will adore these soft pretzels without baking soda, they are such a short bake you can make them over and over again!

More Yummy Baked Goods

Soft Pretzel Balls and Beer Cheese Fondue - a more traditional soft pretzel, with that dark golden sheen and served with the most delicious beer cheese
Perfect English Scones - super soft and tender
Three Cheese Stuffed Soft Pretzels - cheddar, parmesan and cream cheese rolled inside a soft pretzel
Blueberry Crumb Muffins + Video - these are the most amazing blueberry muffins, the secret ingredient really makes them special
Better Than Starbucks Pumpkin Scones - everyone says these are better than Starbucks brand pumpkin scones
Great Grandma's Cinnamon Apple Dutch Baby - a recipe passed down from generations with a slight modern twist, it has big puffy edges and is so delicious

Make sure to follow the Modern Crumb Board on Pinterest for lots of yummy meal inspiration! And subscribe to the newsletter, below, to get updates when new recipes post.